Fork me on GitHub
Math for the people, by the people.

User login

square roots of rationals

Synonym: 
accurate square roots of rationals
Type of Math Object: 
Topic
Major Section: 
Reference
Parent: 
Groups audience: 

Mathematics Subject Classification

11A25 no label found12F05 no label found

Comments

I think it's a vast overstatement to say that the forms

sqrt(1.8) and sqrt(5/3)

are not acceptable. In fact, I think that in many situations they should be preferred. While I concede that it's handy for an instructor to be able to immediately glance at a solution and see whether or not it agrees with the one standard answer, I think the pedagogical cost of arbitrarily dictating that other forms are not acceptable is too high.

I would rephrase the entry as presenting a procedure for putting expressions like the ones above into a standard form, without issuing any judgment on which is better.

Cam

You may be right -- I will alter the expression.

Subscribe to Comments for "square roots of rationals"